Breaking New Ground: SEC No-Action Letter Clears Path for DePIN Token Distributions

October 23rd, 2025

How the DoubleZero ruling signals the SEC's shift to pro-innovation crypto regulation in 2025

By Bo Howell
Crafted with Claude 4.5 Sonnet and Grok 4 Fast

The SEC is flipping the script on crypto regulation—from aggressive enforcement to proactive partnership. Just weeks after new Chair Paul Atkins pledged to roll out innovation exemptions for digital assets, the Division of Corporation Finance dropped a game-changer.

On September 29, 2025, the SEC issued a landmark no-action letter to DoubleZero, greenlighting its token distribution model for decentralized physical infrastructure networks (DePIN). This isn't just a win for one project—it's proof of the SEC's pivot toward practical, tailored guidance for blockchain innovation that defies old-school securities rules.

The DoubleZero letter shows the SEC's "regulation by enforcement" era is over. In its place? Real clarity for DePIN projects and beyond, letting builders focus on tech, not lawsuits.

What Is DePIN? The Future of Decentralized Infrastructure

DePIN flips traditional infrastructure on its head. Forget top-down corporations calling the shots. DePIN uses blockchain to build open, peer-to-peer networks where everyday users supply real-world resources—like cloud storage, wireless bandwidth, GPS mapping, or renewable energy.

The magic? Built-in incentives. Node operators and contributors earn tokens as direct pay for their input. These aren't speculative bets on a company's success; they're rewards for tangible work, coded into the network's rules.

In short: DePIN turns users into builders, powering everything from global data grids to community Wi-Fi without a central boss.

The Big Shift: SEC's Move from Crackdown to Collaboration

Context is key. Under Chair Atkins, the SEC is undoing years of "regulatory repression" that chased crypto talent abroad. As detailed in our SEC Crypto Innovation Exemption 2025 guide, Atkins aims to deliver conditional relief for digital assets by year's end.

The DoubleZero no-action letter is Exhibit A. It skips the hammer, opting for a hands-on review of DePIN's unique model. No forcing square pegs into round holes—just smart, case-by-case analysis.

Commissioner Hester Peirce nailed it in her statement: DePIN tokens aren't classic investments. They're tools to spark infrastructure growth.

Why DePIN Tokens Break the Mold

Work Pays, Not Waiting: Tokens reward active contributions (e.g., sharing bandwidth), not passive investing.
No Sales Pitch: Projects don't hawk tokens to fundraisers chasing profits. Distribution happens automatically via smart contracts.
Gig Economy Vibes: Think Uber for infrastructure—earn for services, not stock in a firm.

Peirce put it bluntly: "These aren't shares or profit promises. They're incentives to build real networks."

This targeted approach? It's the thoughtful regulation the industry begged for, ditching blanket enforcement.

Why the Howey Test Misses the Mark for DePIN

The Howey Test has governed securities law for decades: Is it money invested in a common venture, expecting profits from the efforts of others?DePIN says no. Here's why:

No Investment Mindset: Users provide services, getting paid in tokens—not handing over cash for returns.
Active, Not Passive: It's hands-on work, like freelancing, not passive income.
Network-Driven, Not Promoter-Powered: Profits (if any) come from collective effort, not a CEO's hustle.

Peirce drove it home: "DePIN's economic reality isn't capital-raising—it's service coordination. Calling these tokens securities would stifle distributed innovation."

Result? DePIN dodges Howey, freeing projects to scale without SEC registration fears.

What DoubleZero's No-Action Letter Delivers

The letter's bottom line: DoubleZero's token transfers are exempt from registration under Section 5 of the Securities Act and Section 12(g) of the Exchange Act. There is no need to treat them as equity securities.

Caveat: It's fact-specific. Stick to DoubleZero's setup—programmatic rewards for verified contributions—or risk a different SEC call.

This isn't a free pass for all tokens. It's a blueprint for compliant DePIN design.

Ripple Effects: Turbocharging Blockchain Innovation

One letter, massive impact. Paired with Atkins' innovation exemption framework, it spotlights the SEC's new playbook: Engage early, relieve wisely.

The Broader Vision

Lower Hurdles: Innovate without six-figure legal bills for shaky compliance.
Certainty Wins: Swap gray-area gambles for upfront SEC nods.
U.S. Revival: Level the field against crypto havens like Singapore or Dubai.

Peirce warned: "Don't cram blockchain into outdated molds. Let markets judge DePIN's success—not regulators."It's engagement at its best: Precise, principle-based, and pro-growth.

DePIN Project Checklist: Stay Compliant in the New Era

Clarity is gold, but details matter. For DePIN builders:

Tailor to Facts: Mirror DoubleZero's service-based distributions—deviations could void relief.
Document Everything: Prove tokens = compensation, not speculation. Audit trails save headaches.
Design Smart: Lock in rule-based minting; avoid manual giveaways.
Evolve Carefully: Monitor network changes to keep Howey at bay.

Miss these? You might land in exemption territory instead.

DePIN's Place in the SEC's 2025 Crypto Roadmap

Timing is everything. This letter lands amid Atkins' three-pronged clarity push:

Targeted No-Action Letters: Like DoubleZero—for clear non-securities like DePIN rewards.
Innovation Exemptions: Sandbox-style relief for edgier plays (DeFi, tokenization). Explore the framework here.
Full Rulemaking: Long-term rules that fit blockchain's quirks.

Tailored Paths Forward

Pure DePIN: Ride the no-action wave—no registration needed.
Hybrid Projects (DeFi/Payments): Gear up for exemptions with built-in compliance hooks.
Scale-Ups: Use interim tools while permanent rules brew.

Skeptics like Momentum Finance's Wendy Fu question if it'll stick: "Rules must match crypto's reality—or it's all show." DoubleZero hints at yes: Deep dives over dogma.

Still, consult counsel. One-size-fits-all is dead, but facts rule.

Reclaiming U.S. Leadership in Crypto and Blockchain

This isn't DePIN-exclusive—it's a wake-up for all digital assets. The SEC's evolving stance recognizes tokens' roles: Utility in DePIN, speculation elsewhere.

Global Stakes

U.S. crypto lagged as rivals surged:

EU's MiCA: Clear rules drawing billions.
Asia's Hubs: Singapore/Switzerland/UAE host thriving ecosystems.
China's Pivot: Blockchain Bets Minus Trading Bans.

Offshoring was the fix. Now? DoubleZero + exemptions could lure talent home. Clearpool's Jakob Kronbichler sees it: "Bridging innovation and rules—U.S. style."DePIN could boom: Think tokenized grids powering AI data centers or EV charging webs.

Actionable Steps: Master the Regulatory Reset

Whether DePIN, DeFi, or beyond, here's your roadmap:

DePIN/Infrastructure Focus

Audit token flows for service-proof purity.
Map contributions to rewards with ironclad logs.
Pre-vet via counsel for DoubleZero alignment.

DeFi/Tokenization/Payments

Eye exemption eligibility—prep for conditional sandboxes.
Flex your code for governance tweaks.
Weigh U.S. return if offshore.

Universal Best Practices

Hire securities pros for bespoke reviews.
Join rulemaking comments—shape the future.
Build compliance docs like a fortress.
Track custody/stablecoin rules in parallel.

No-Action Letter Snapshot

Issuer: SEC Division of Corporation Finance
Date: September 29, 2025
To: DoubleZero
Key Relief: Exempts token transfers from Sections 5 and 12(g) registration

Must-Reads:

Partner with FinTech Law for Crypto Compliance

Navigating SEC shifts? Our experts decode no-action letters, exemptions, and more for DePIN, DeFi, and blockchain ventures.

DePIN Services:

Token model audits against DoubleZero standards
Compliant network blueprints
SEC request prep

DeFi & Beyond:

Exemption roadmaps
Utility token structuring
Onshoring strategies

Holistic Support:

Rulemaking intel
Compliance audits
Tech-law fusion

The 2025 reset is real—but execution counts. As our innovation exemption deep-dive shows, smart structuring turns opportunity into edge.

Ready to build compliant? Contact us for a free consult on SEC's crypto evolution.