AI and Fixed Legal Fees: The Savings Split Is a Negotiation

Tredennick's Fixed-Fee Case and the $10,000 Question
Under Virginia's ethics opinion, the rules do not settle how much of the AI savings a client receives on a fixed fee. In a LawSites guest post published November 2, 2026, John Tredennick argues that AI gives firms a new reason to move beyond the billable hour. His illustrative project costs a firm $80,000 to deliver and is priced at $100,000. If a better process reduces delivery cost to $40,000, the firm could charge $70,000: the client saves $30,000 and the firm's profit rises from $20,000 to $30,000.
Here is the detail in that example worth reading twice. Delivery cost fell by $40,000. The client's price fell by $30,000. The other $10,000 went to the firm, and Virginia Legal Ethics Opinion 1901, approved by the Supreme Court of Virginia on November 24, 2025, states that Rule 1.5 "should not require the lawyer to surrender any benefit from the efficiency gains if clients continue to receive value from the lawyer's output."
For the founder or CFO who buys legal services, under that opinion, AI efficiency on a fixed-fee matter is a pricing term to negotiate, not a discount that arrives on its own.
Hourly Bills and Fixed Fees Follow Different Rules
The distinction that matters is the billing model. On an hourly matter, the rule is settled. ABA Formal Opinion 512, issued July 29, 2024 as the ABA's first formal ethics opinion on generative AI, says lawyers who bill hourly must bill for their actual time, so a lawyer who drafts faster with AI may not charge for hours not spent. Virginia's opinion agrees that time-based billing "can only be based on the actual time spent on a task."
On a fixed fee, Virginia's opinion goes further. Virginia LEO 1901 states that "it is not per se unreasonable for a lawyer to charge the same non-hourly fee for work done with the assistance of AI as work done without the use of AI." Its reasoning is that while AI can reduce "the time and labor required," the "skill requisite to perform the legal service properly" might increase, because effective AI use can require knowledge to prompt, verify, supplement, and integrate AI output.
Virginia's opinion dismisses contrary views: "Contrary views fail to appreciate the value of advancing technology and the reaction of the legal markets to that technology."
Why this split changes your bill
- Hourly: AI efficiency reaches you through fewer billed hours, because the firm may bill only actual time.
- Fixed fee: AI efficiency reaches you only as far as the price you negotiate, and under Virginia's opinion a firm need not reduce the fee based solely on reduced time.
What the 2027 Survey Data Shows, and What It Does Not
The 2027 Best Law Firms U.S. Legal Market Report, drawing on survey responses from 5,753 law firms, found that 70% of surveyed firms offer alternative fee arrangements, down from 72% the previous year. Flat fees (69%), retainers (63%), and contingency fees (59%) were among the most commonly offered. That measures how many firms offer the arrangements. It does not measure how much legal work is actually priced that way.
The AI figures are more telling. Among firms using GenAI, 25% reported reduced billable hours for certain tasks, up from 19%. Another 27% reported increased efficiency without changes to billable hours. One of Tredennick's lines from his talks was that more people talk about alternative billing than actually do it.
The operational lesson from the builders
Tredennick's case for fixed fees rests on discipline, not optimism. He credits project managers on Beaver Creek condominium developments with teaching him to map the work, estimate each task, and track progress against the plan. Applied to AI, he writes that a firm must "understand the work, account for the technology and supervision, and measure what the new process actually costs" before it can price with confidence.
What Your Leadership Team Should Decide Before the Next Engagement Letter
The founder or CFO who owns outside legal spend should treat AI efficiency as a negotiated term. These steps follow from the sources above.
Contract terms to request
- Price by phase, with written assumptions. Tredennick writes that a unique, open-ended case may call for pricing a defined phase, spelling out assumptions, and agreeing on how to handle changes in scope.
- Ask how AI changes the work. Virginia's opinion separately requires that a fee be adequately explained to the client under Rule 1.5(b), so ask the firm to explain the basis of a fixed price on AI-assisted work.
- Name the savings split. Use Tredennick's own example as the reference point: on his numbers, the client received $30,000 of a $40,000 cost reduction.
Controls to run internally
- Audit hourly invoices against actual time. Under Opinion 512, AI-assisted hourly work is billable only for time actually spent.
- Keep your own history. Track what each category of matter cost you, from RIA registration to fund documents, so you can test the next fixed quote against real numbers.
Best Law Firms' senior research manager Valerie Smith put the market question plainly: firms "will need to be clear about how work is changing and how those efficiencies are reflected in the service clients receive."
Key Takeaways
The points below are drawn from the guest post, the two ethics opinions, and the 2027 survey.
- Hourly AI work is billable only for actual time. ABA Formal Opinion 512 says lawyers who bill hourly must bill for the time they actually spend.
- Virginia does not treat the same fixed fee with or without AI as per se unreasonable. LEO 1901 states that charging the same non-hourly fee for AI-assisted work is not per se unreasonable, subject to Rule 1.5's overall reasonableness test.
- Under Virginia's opinion, your share of AI savings on a fixed fee is negotiated. In Tredennick's illustration, a $40,000 cost reduction became a $30,000 client saving and $10,000 of added firm profit.
- Offering alternative fees is not the same as using them. The 2027 Best Law Firms survey reports that 70% of surveyed firms offer alternative fee arrangements, a measure of availability, not of revenue share.
The Engagement Letter Is Where AI Savings Get Allocated
AI can lower the cost of producing legal work, and on fixed-fee matters the engagement letter decides who keeps the difference. Firms buying RIA registration, fund formation, or ongoing compliance work generally need the scope, assumptions, and change-in-scope terms of each engagement written down before the work starts, along with a clear explanation of how AI-assisted work is priced. FinTech Law, an AI-native securities law firm, handles that work as RIA counsel for founders and fund managers; start the conversation here.
FinTech Law's startup counsel team works with founders on the formation, fundraising, and contract work where these fee terms apply.
This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content. If you need legal advice, please contact a qualified attorney.
FinTech Law fixed engagements: FinTech Startup Regulatory Path ($1,500) · Emerging Manager Launch Kit ($7,500) · Regulatory Path Outline ($7,500) · RIA/ERA Registration ($8,500) · Private Fund Formation (from ~$18,000) See the catalog.
Fractional General Counsel · from $7,500/qtr