FinTech Law Blog

NYSBA AI Billing Guidance: Pay for the Review, Not the Time AI Saved

November 20, 20265 min read

NYSBA AI Billing Guidance: Pay for the Review, Not the Time AI Saved

New York's AI Billing Guidance Turns on Time Actually Spent

The New York State Bar Association's House of Delegates adopted the "Legal Ethics Guidelines for Lawyers' Use of Artificial Intelligence" on October 31, 2026, and under them a lawyer billing hourly may bill only for time actually expended, not for time that would have been spent had an AI tool not been used. The ABA Journal reported the guidelines on November 3, 2026, under the headline "New York State Bar Association tells lawyers not to bill for time saved by AI." The report came from the bar's Committee on Artificial Intelligence and Emerging Technologies.

But here is the part that headline compresses. The approved guidelines treat the time a lawyer spends writing prompts and reviewing, verifying and revising AI output as billable. The hour does not disappear. It moves from producing the first draft to checking it.

For a company paying hourly legal bills to New York lawyers, that changes what a defensible invoice entry looks like. Prompting and review are on the list of billable work. The hours the tool saved are not.

Guidance, Not a Rule: What the House of Delegates Adopted

The ABA Journal's own text is more measured than its headline. It says the association "is calling for restrictions" on how much lawyers can bill for time saved using AI tools or spent learning how to use them. That is the accurate frame for a board conversation.

According to one analysis of the guidelines, they "do not amend the New York Rules of Professional Conduct" and do not create independent disciplinary obligations. They apply the existing rules, including Rule 1.5 on fees, to AI use. NYSBA President Taa Grays framed the purpose in a statement: "Generative AI is indelibly changing the practice of law."

The billing position is also not new in New York. NYC Bar Formal Opinion 2024-5, issued August 7, 2024, already stated that a lawyer "must not charge hourly fees for the time that would otherwise have been spent absent" generative AI, according to a New York AI ethics tracker. Nationally, the ABA issued Formal Opinion 512 on July 29, 2024, its first formal ethics opinion on generative AI, as ABA Business Law Today summarized. What October 31 adds is a set of ethics guidelines on AI billing and disclosure adopted by the statewide bar's governing body.

Overhead Versus Disbursement: Where AI Costs Land on Your Invoice

The distinction that matters for legal budgets is between firm overhead and a matter expense. Law360, as reported by the ABA Journal, says the report classifies the cost of buying and maintaining AI software as an overhead expense that can be passed along as a disbursement only when tied to a specific client matter and when the basis for the charge has been disclosed.

That gives a finance team a clean test for any AI line item:

  • Is it tied to your specific matter? A general tool cost is overhead under the report's approach.
  • Was the basis disclosed? A matter-specific charge passes through only with a disclosed basis.
  • Is it learning time? The ABA Journal reports the bar is calling for restrictions on billing for time spent learning how to use AI tools.

Disclosure runs on a fee trigger as well. According to Law360, lawyers generally need not tell clients about AI used for administrative tasks such as word processing, spelling and grammar checks, calendaring or timekeeping, provided the use does not affect fees.

Verification is the work you are paying for

The report also reminds supervising lawyers that they remain responsible for their subordinates' compliance and should not assume that a firm-approved tool or policy removes the need to review work on each matter. Read together with the billing guidance, the review step is both the ethical obligation and the billable entry. A bill that shows AI-assisted drafting with no visible review time may raise questions about who checked the work.

What Your Leadership Team Should Ask Outside Firms This Quarter

These questions apply first to New York law firms, since the guidelines are New York State Bar Association guidance. The questions on time entries apply to hourly engagements; the questions on disbursements and review apply to any matter where a firm uses AI.

Questions for the next engagement letter

  1. Ask which AI tools are used on your matters. You cannot evaluate an AI disbursement without knowing what tool generated it.
  2. Ask how AI-assisted time appears on invoices. Under the guidelines, hourly entries reflect prompting and review, not the hours a tool saved.
  3. Ask for the basis of any AI disbursement in writing. The report, as described by Law360, conditions pass-through on a specific matter and a disclosed basis.
  4. Ask who reviews AI output on each matter. A firm-approved tool does not remove the need for matter-level review.

Who owns the fix

  • The CFO or whoever approves legal spend owns invoice review against these questions.
  • The general counsel owns the engagement terms and directs outside counsel to state the AI billing basis.
  • The CEO should know the answer before the next large matter is staffed.

Key Takeaways

The guidelines shift what an hourly legal bill should contain. They do not change the binding rules.

  • Time AI saved is not billable hourly time under the NYSBA guidelines. Lawyers billing hourly may bill only for time actually expended.
  • Prompting and verification remain billable. Writing prompts and reviewing, verifying and revising AI output count as time actually spent.
  • AI tool costs are overhead by default. According to Law360, they pass through as a disbursement only when tied to a specific matter with a disclosed basis.
  • The guidelines are guidance, not a rule change. They do not amend the New York Rules of Professional Conduct or create independent disciplinary obligations.
  • The engagement letter is where the terms belong. Ask which tools are used on your matters and how AI time and costs will appear on invoices.

Pay for the Review, and Put It in Writing

The New York guidelines make verification, not the drafting a tool displaced, the billable work on hourly matters that use AI. Companies opening new matters with New York firms can address AI-use, billing and disbursement terms in their engagement letters. FinTech Law is an AI-native securities law firm and startup counsel for founders and executives. To have those terms reviewed, talk to FinTech Law.

This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content. If you need legal advice, please contact a qualified attorney.

FinTech Law fixed engagements: FinTech Startup Regulatory Path ($1,500) · Emerging Manager Launch Kit ($7,500) · Regulatory Path Outline ($7,500) · RIA/ERA Registration ($8,500) · Private Fund Formation (from ~$18,000) See the catalog.

Fractional General Counsel · from $7,500/qtr

Share This Blog Post

Fixed price. Clear scope.

Need an answer for your own product?

Two fixed-price ways to find out where you stand, without a full engagement.

Written attorney answer

Limited Document Review

$1,500 fixed fee

Building an AI or fintech product that touches investing? A licensed attorney reviews your documents and tells you, in writing, whether you need to register as an investment adviser or may rely on an exemption or exclusion.

  • Written memorandum within five business days of your documents
  • No call required
  • Tells you which product features push toward registration

Self-serve tool

RIA Registration Path Scorecard

$199 or $99 with supporting documents

Sorting out SEC, exempt reporting adviser, or state registration? Answer a short set of questions and get a first-read map of your likely path. It sits upstream of counsel and is not a registration opinion.

  • Built for venture, private fund, and robo or AI advisers
  • Start now, with no call
  • A clear next step if you need counsel