Resources · Guides
Does the publisher's exclusion cover your newsletter, research service, or app?
Updated: November 2026
A newsletter, research service, or app that gives investment commentary is not an investment adviser if it fits the publisher's exclusion in Section 202(a)(11)(D) of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. Under Lowe v. SEC (1985), that generally means the content is impersonal (not tailored to any reader's portfolio or needs), bona fide (genuine, disinterested commentary rather than promotion), and of general and regular circulation (published on a regular basis and not timed to specific market activity). The more a product personalizes, times its calls to market moves, or acts for its users, the weaker the exclusion becomes.
The test
The three features of an excluded publication
| Feature | What it means | What cuts against it |
|---|---|---|
| Impersonal | Every subscriber gets the same content. Nothing is tailored to a reader's holdings, goals, or situation. | Answering subscribers' questions about their own portfolios; recommendations built from information a user supplies |
| Bona fide | Genuine, disinterested commentary and analysis. | Promoting securities the publisher or its affiliates hold or are paid to promote; content that is really marketing for another business |
| General and regular circulation | Offered to the public on a regular schedule. | Alerts timed to specific market activity; irregular messages sent when the author wants subscribers to act |
The Supreme Court's point in Lowe was that the Advisers Act is aimed at people who give personalized advice attuned to a client's concerns. A publication that discusses specific securities is not, for that reason alone, an investment adviser.
Fact patterns
How common fintech products tend to fare
| Product | How it tends to fare |
|---|---|
| Daily or weekly market newsletter (email, Substack, X) | Often fits, if the content is the same for everyone and published on a schedule. Check for paid promotions and one-on-one reader Q&A. |
| Real-time trade alerts or signal channels (Telegram, Discord, SMS) | Needs a close look. Calls timed to market moves can cut against regular circulation. |
| App with AI-generated insights, summaries, or scores | General analytics shown to every user can look like publishing. Features that use a user's holdings, goals, or risk profile to suggest actions look more like personalized advice. |
| Copy-trading or automatic trade execution | Placing or mirroring trades for users is unlikely to be treated as publishing, and it can raise broker-dealer questions as well. |
| Paid community with direct access to the author | Group content can fit. Individual advice to members about their own situations is personalized advice. |
Next step
If the exclusion does not fit
A business that gives investment advice for compensation and does not fit an exclusion is generally an investment adviser. Most advisers with less than $100 million in regulatory assets under management register with their state rather than the SEC, unless an exemption allows SEC registration, such as the internet adviser exemption for advice given only through an interactive website.
State law has its own definitions and exclusions, so a business that would register with a state should check that state's rules too.
Get a written answer
Limited Document Review: $1,500, no call
For a fixed $1,500, a licensed FinTech Law attorney reviews your documents, such as your terms of service, a description of your product, and your pricing, and sends a written memorandum on whether your business is an investment adviser and whether the publisher's exclusion, or another exemption or exclusion, may apply.
You receive the memorandum within five business days after you accept the terms, pay, and provide your documents. No call is needed. What you share is kept confidential.
Talk with counsel
Qualified inquiries go through FinTech Law contact intake. Meetings are scheduled after qualification.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Whether the publisher's exclusion applies depends on the facts of your business. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading it.